11.2 C
New York

NDP Leader Clarifies Comments Amid Criticism from Liberal MPs

Published:

NDP Leader Avi Lewis clarified that he does not hold all Jewish individuals accountable for the policies of Israel regarding Gaza, following criticism from some Liberal MPs who labeled his recent social media comments as irresponsible and “despicable.”

In a post made late Sunday, Lewis expressed that he would be observing Yom Kippur, the most sacred day in the Jewish calendar, by contemplating geopolitical issues.

“For Jewish people, the personal has always intertwined with the political. This year, I’m reflecting on the reality that we have not done enough to prevent an ongoing genocide happening in our name,” Lewis stated on the social media platform X on Sunday evening.

His comments did not explicitly refer to the conflict in Gaza, which escalated in October 2023 after Hamas launched a surprise attack on Israel, resulting in the deaths of 1,200 individuals and the abduction of around 250 hostages.

A social media post from NDP Leader Avi Lewis on X.

Avi Lewis made this post on Sunday, the start of Yom Kippur. (@avilewis/X)

Since that incident, tens of thousands of Palestinians have died due to nearly three years of Israeli airstrikes often targeting civilian areas and policies that have led to an international famine declaration.

Liberal MPs Anthony Housefather and Ben Carr both expressed their disapproval of Lewis’s remarks, asserting that it is incorrect to collectively blame Jews for Israel’s actions.

When asked if he believed Lewis’s post was antisemitic, Carr described it as “naive.”

“That’s an irresponsible statement from a leader,” remarked the Winnipeg MP.

“It’s dangerous and perpetuates a narrative that contributes to the threats faced by the Jewish community.”

Housefather took to X to label Lewis’s comments as “despicable.”

The federal government’s definition of antisemitism warns against attributing collective blame to Jews for the actions of Israel, stating that such views can incite anti-Jewish hatred.

This idea of collective responsibility has been connected to numerous attacks on Jewish institutions, including a shooting incident on Sunday outside a synagogue in Belleville, Ontario, while worshippers were present to observe Yom Kippur.

Lewis’s post was made shortly before this shooting, which the Special Investigations Unit reported involved a 29-year-old man allegedly discharging a firearm at a police officer stationed outside the synagogue for protection.

On Monday, Lewis condemned the attack, first in a post on X just ahead of question period, and subsequently when a reporter questioned him during a scrum at Parliament Hill.

“It’s terrifying,” he remarked. “I can easily imagine what it would be like to be in a synagogue and hear gunfire in a place so familiar to me. It’s an extremely frightening experience. It’s horrible.”

During the same scrum, he stated that the backlash to his comments regarding Israel was politically motivated.

“It’s quite disheartening to see these partisan points being made in this context,” he noted.

“Blaming Jews collectively for the actions of the Israeli government is antisemitic. I have never done that. I believe it’s dangerous, and that’s absolutely not what I intended.”

“I spoke as a Jewish Canadian from a place of deep sorrow.… Many Jews have expressed that we have not done enough as Jewish individuals, alongside a global community of faiths and groups.”

Some individuals, including former Canadian ambassador to Israel Jon Allen, argue that prominent Jewish organizations in Canada create a misleading impression of their stance on Israel’s actions against Palestinians by not vocally opposing the Israeli government.

Allen testified before a Senate committee this past June, stating, “By remaining silent about the situation in the West Bank and Gaza, there is a complicity of silence,” adding that he is Jewish himself.

“The Jewish community’s occasional failure to speak out against the Israeli government’s actions leads people in Canada to question whether they support everything Israel does, including the events in Gaza,” he testified.

Related articles

Recent articles