According to CBC News, the individual charged with the death of a six-year-old boy due to impaired driving in St. John’s last month had been involved in another accident just two days prior. However, police officers present at that earlier incident did not perform a background check on him.
If a check had been conducted, authorities would have discovered that 32-year-old Tyler Day had an active arrest warrant.
On July 21, Day was operating a work vehicle when he collided with another car at the junction of Stamp’s Lane and Terra Nova Road. Although the other vehicle incurred significant damage, no critical injuries were reported.
The Royal Newfoundland Constabulary (RNC) explained that a check on Day was not performed because the incident was deemed “non-criminal.”
“Police interactions are determined by the nature of the service call,” stated RNC Const. Stephanie Myers.
“In this instance, there was no information necessitating officers to conduct criminal record checks; the non-criminal issue was resolved, and the case was closed.”
Two days later, when Day is reportedly accused of hitting six-year-old Zafeer Munir at the intersection of Thorburn Road and Larkhall Street, police became aware of the outstanding warrant.

Zafeer Munir, aged six, succumbed to his injuries days after the incident near the intersection of Thorburn Road and Larkhall Street on the evening of July 23. (Submitted by Munir family)
Authorities reported that Day fled the scene but was pursued by a witness. He was apprehended nearby on Cumberland Crescent. Initially charged with impaired driving resulting in bodily harm, the charges were later elevated to impaired driving causing death after the boy passed away.
In addition, he faces charges of dangerous driving resulting in death, criminal negligence leading to death, and failing to remain at the scene of an accident that caused death.
Former Officer States Day Probably Would Have Been Released
The original warrant for Day’s arrest was issued in January 2025 due to alleged violations of a court order in Corner Brook, where he was charged with fraud involving less than $5,000.
Michael Arntfield, a criminologist and former police officer, mentioned that if the RNC had acted on the warrant on July 21, it is likely Day would have been released before the tragic incident on July 23.
“Ultimately, we will never know if the result could have been different had his name or vehicle details been properly checked and he was arrested on that warrant,” Arntfield commented. “He could have easily been released on bail that day or the next and still been driving on the 23rd.”

Michael Arntfield, a criminologist, dedicated 15 years to police work in London, Ontario, and now teaches at the University of Western Ontario. (CBC)
Arntfield expressed surprise at the lack of a background check on Day’s information during the first incident.
“I find this quite surprising, not only from a service delivery angle but also considering officer safety,” he remarked. “Every police interaction has the potential to be criminal. What starts as one situation may evolve into something entirely different.”
He noted that throughout his 15 years of experience in policing, it was standard procedure to run individuals’ information through the Canadian Police Information Centre (CPIC) at the beginning of each engagement.
“What if he had been prohibited from driving due to a previous impaired driving conviction? That would have been an immediate arrestable offense,” Arntfield stated. “The only way for the officer to be aware of that is by checking the name.”
Day was subject to an endorsed warrant, meaning RNC officers had the discretion to either take him into custody or release him on a promise to appear in court later. While the warrant was for a lesser offense, it is significant that he had been sought by police for over a year.
Regardless of whether he was detained on July 21, Arntfield emphasized that it is nearly certain he would have been released prior to the fatal incident two days later.
“It’s just a series of unfortunate events that led to this tragedy,” he concluded.
Day, who is still in custody, is scheduled to appear in court on September 8 for a status update. The court has been informed that he is working on a plan for release and intends to pursue bail.
Download our free CBC News app to sign up for push alerts for CBC Newfoundland and Labrador. Sign up for our daily headlines newsletter here. Click here to visit our landing page.
